Effectiveness of the ICARE-Modification Model in Training Students’ Critical Thinking Skills
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.56707/ijoerar.v4i2.168Keywords:
ICARE-modification, Critical thinking, AI-assisted learning, Students, LectureAbstract
Objective: Developing students’ critical thinking skills remains a central challenge in higher education, particularly in teacher education programs that demand higher-order cognitive competencies. This study investigates the effectiveness of the ICARE-Modification model—an extended instructional framework integrating Introduction, Connection, Application-modification, Reflection, and Extension stages with AI problem-solving activities—in enhancing undergraduate students’ critical thinking skills. Method: A quasi-experimental design with a non-equivalent control group was employed involving 60 undergraduate students enrolled in a teacher education program. The experimental group received instruction using the ICARE-Modification model, while the control group experienced conventional lecture-based learning. Data were collected through a validated open-ended critical thinking test assessed using an analytical rubric covering questioning, analysis, evaluation, logical reasoning, and solution formulation. Data were analyzed using independent samples t-tests and Cohen’s d effect size. Results: The findings suggest that the ICARE-Modification model creates a more interactive and cognitively engaging learning environment that supports the development of students’ critical thinking skills. Through structured stages of learning that involve exploration, discussion, and reflection, students are encouraged to actively construct knowledge and evaluate their own reasoning processes, which ultimately leads to better learning outcomes in critical thinking. Novelty: This study introduces the ICARE-Modification model, an extended instructional framework that integrates the traditional ICARE stages with AI-assisted problem-solving activities to foster students’ critical thinking skills in teacher education. Unlike previous studies that apply ICARE as a conventional instructional model, this research incorporates structured cognitive scaffolding and AI-supported reflective learning to enhance higher-order thinking processes.
References
Ahman, E., Dahlan, D., & Supendra, D. (2025). Identifying Key Factors Influencing the Development of Higher Order Thinking Skills ( HOTS ) in Students : A Systematic Literature Review. 17(2010), 5242–5257. https://doi.org/10.35445/alishlah.v17i3.6627
Anggraini, A. E., Subuatningsih, O. A., Khotimah, K., Kang, E., & Sufian, M. (2024). Thematic Learning Tools Based on Collaborative Learning Models for Grade IV Elementary School. 8(4), 670–678.
Ariadila, S., Silalahi, Y., Fadiyah, F., Jamaludin, U., & Setiawan, S. (2023). Analisis Pentingnya Keterampilan Berpikir Kritis Terhadap Pembelajaran Bagi Siswa. 9(20), 664–669. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.8436970
Elok, S., Fatkhi, S., & Solihah, M. (2023). Integrative Science Education and Teaching Activity Journal Application of The Inquiry Based ICARE Learning Model Toward Cognitive Learning Outcomes on Salt Hydrolysis Material. 4(2), 231–244.
Endrawan, I. B., & Aliriad, H. (2023). Problem-Based Collaborative Learning Model Improves Physical Education Learning Outcomes for Elementary School Students. 11(1), 9–17.
Gazali, F., & Dasna, I. W. (2023). Edukatif : Jurnal Ilmu Pendidikan Meningkatkan Keterampilan Berpikir Kritis Siswa dalam Pembelajaran Kimia : Sebuah Studi Literatur. 5(3), 1403–1414.
Hidayati, A., Hidayat, H., Ardi, Z., Rahmi, U., & Saputra, A. (2025). Enhancing Higher Order Thinking Skill ( HOTS ) through Student Engagement and Learning Support. 15(9), 1842–1852. https://doi.org/10.18178/ijiet.2025.15.9.2385
Ibtidaiyah, M. (2024). ANALISIS MODEL CRITICAL THINKING PADA KONTEN FIKIH DI MADRASAH IBTIDAIYAH Hikmatu Ruwaida STIQ Amuntai , Kalimantan Selatan , Indonesia Nida Mauizdati STIQ Amuntai , Kalimantan Selatan , Indonesia Abstrak Al-Madrasah : Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan Madrasah Ib. 8(1), 390–408. https://doi.org/10.35931/am.v8i1.2883
Indah, P., & Borneo, E. (2020). Development of HOTS ( High Order Thinking Skill ) Increase The Critical Thinking Skill of High School. 4(April). https://doi.org/10.20885/ijcer.vol
Jatiningsih, O. (2025). High Order Thinking Skills ( HOTS ) Analysis of Grade VIII Junior High School Students on the Subject of Preserving My Nation ’ s Culture. 3(4), 1–16.
Jusriana, A. (2024). The Effect of ICARE Learning Model on Students ’ Learning Outcomes in Physics Learning Class XI SMAN 13 Makassar. 1(3), 65–69.
Karim, M., Syafrul Antoni, & Karlini Oktarina. (2024). Meta-Analysis of Collaborative Learning Approaches in Educational Management and Their Impact on Student Performance. Indonesia Journal of Engineering and Education Technology (IJEET), 2(2), 427–434. https://doi.org/10.61991/ijeet.v2i2.85
Karmila, W., Achmad, S., & Utami, U. (2023). High-Order Questions Improve Students ’ Critical Thinking Skills In Elementary Schools. 7(2), 196–203.
Latifa, A., Nur, R., & Rizal, A. (2020). ICARE Learning Model in Improving the Students Writing Ability. 4(2), 258–269.
Latifah, A. (2023). COLLABORATIVE LEARNING IN THE DIGITAL ERA : STRATEGIES TO PREPARE PRIMARY SCHOOL STUDENTS TO FACE THE CHALLENGES OF THE 21ST CENTURY. 7(1), 67–76.
Mardliyah, S. Z., Salsabilla, A. P., Luthfi, N., & Herianingtyas, R. (2023). STRATEGI PENINGKATAN KEMAMPUAN BERPIKIR KRITIS. 6.
Mawaddah, F. (2024). Development of E-Modules Based on the ICARE Learning Model to Improve Students ’ Creative Thinking and Scientific Communication Skills. 10(7), 4397–4403. https://doi.org/10.29303/jppipa.v10i7.7747
Melawati, Y., & Rosidin, U. (2023). International Journal of Current Science Research and Review Development of A Higher-Order Thinking Skills ( HOTS ) Instrument to Measure Student ’ s Critical Thinking Abilities in Class V Elementary School. 06(12), 8170–8176. https://doi.org/10.47191/ijcsrr/V6-i12-70
Mimhamimdala, F., & Nirwana, H. (2023). Populer Learning Theory : Collaborative Learning. 1(2), 292–302.
Moreira-Choez, J. S., Lamus de Rodríguez, T. M., Núñez-Naranjo, A. F., Sabando-García, Á. R., Reinoso-Ávalos, M. B., Olguín-Martínez, C. M., Nieves-Lizárraga, D. O., & Salazar-Echeagaray, J. E. (2025). Validation of a teaching model instrument for university education in Ecuador through an artificial intelligence algorithm. Frontiers in Education, 10. https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2025.1473524
Mulyani, A. Y. (2022). Pengembangan Critical Thinking Dalam Peningkatan Mutu Pendidikan di Indonesia. 1(1), 100–105. https://doi.org/10.54259/diajar.v1i1.226
Nadia, H. (2025). Implementation of Collaborative Learning through Learning Communities to Improve Teacher Professional Competence. 2(1), 30–37.
Nikmah, F. K., Singgih, S., & Muhlisin, A. (2025). The Effectiveness of the Introduction, Connection, Application, Reflection, Extension (ICARE) Learning Model in Improving Higher Order Thinking Skills (HOTS) of Junior High School Students. Paedagogia: Jurnal Pendidikan, 14(2), 223–240. https://doi.org/10.24239/pdg.vol14.iss2.982
Nisa, H., Isnaini, M., & Utami, L. S. (2023). Collaborative Learning Effect on Improving Stu dents ’ Creativity and Critical Thinking in the Independent Curriculum. 15, 4038–4048. https://doi.org/10.35445/alishlah.v15i3.3538
Norsaniyah, S., Jadid, U. N., Java, E., & Outcames, L. (2025). Collaborative learning strategies to improve student learning outcomes. 03(01), 472–479.
Nyoman, N., Darmayanti, Y., Ngurah, G., & Agustika, S. (2025). ICARE-Based Animated Video Learning Media on Data Presentation in Mathematics for Fourth Grade Elementary School Students. 9, 31–42.
Oktavianty, E., Tms, H., Sirait, J., & Supriadi, Y. (2020). Physics Higher Order Thinking Skills Analysis : Motion at Secondary School. 13103–13110.
Primahesa, A., Ramli, M., Education, B., Science, E., & Maret, U. S. (2023). Improving higher order thinking skills in high school biology: A systematic review. 16(1), 206–218.
Putra, E. D., Pradana, P. H., & Triwahyuni, E. (2024). Implementation of the Introduce Connect Apply Reflect Extend ( ICARE ) Model Learning Flow in developing online modules based on U-Learning Class LMS. 9(1), 1309–1321. https://doi.org/10.29303/jppipa.v10i3.7160
Putri, E., & Fatmawati, L. (2024). Analysis of High Order Thinking Skills ( HOTS ) in Objective Test Questions for Science Learning Material in Fourth Grade Elementary School. 3(03), 137–144. https://doi.org/10.56741/ijlree.v3i03.624
Putri, S., Rosmiati, Sudarmano, M., Subaedah, & Nengsih, R. (2025). PENERAPAN MODEL CRITICAL THINKING DALAM MENINGKATKAN HASIL BELAJAR MTs BHAYANGKARA TALLO MAKASSAR. 10.
Rahardhian, A. (2022). Kajian Kemampuan Berpikir Kritis ( Critical Thinking Skill ) dari Sudut Pandang Filsafat. 5(2), 87–94.
Rahmadhani, Suci., Amiruddin Siahaan, I. J. (2022). ANALISIS PENERAPAN MODEL PEMBELAJARAN ICARE UNTUK MENINGKATKAN KEMAMPUAN BERFIKIR KRITIS SISWA DI ERA PANDEMI COVID.19. April, 239–245.
Rayanto, Y. H., & Supriyo. (2022). The Effectiveness of ICARE Model on Micro Teaching Subjects through Hybrid Learning Class. 1(6), 929–938.
Roikha, Aliyatur., Fatimatul Khikmiyah, I. Z. (2023). PENGEMBANGAN LEARNING MANAGEMENT SYSTEM BERBASIS MOODLE MODEL PEMBELAJARAN ICARE PADA MATERI ARITMETIKA SOSIAL. 15, 116–126.
Risda, D., Parsaoran, S., & Efendi, R. (2021). EFEKTIVITAS MODEL ICARE UNTUK MENINGKATKAN KETERAMPILAN. 7, 193–198.
Sappaile, B. I., Mokay, M. M., Supendi, D., Smas, M. H., & Rais, R. (2025). Analysis of the Effectiveness of Collaborative Learning in Enhancing Academic Achievement in Junior High Schools. 04(01), 225–231. https://doi.org/10.55299/ijere.v4i1.925
Saputra, E. E. (2026). Integration of Computer-Based Learning Media and Problem-Based Learning Models to Develop Critical Thinking Abilities in Early Childhood. 7(1), 501–510.
Saputri, M., & Nurlianti, S. (2022). The Effectiveness of ICARE Learning Model in Improving Students ’ Critical Thinking Skills and Collaboration Skills. 8(3). https://doi.org/10.29303/jppipa.v8i3.1360
Setiawan, J., Sudrajat, A., & Kumalasari, D. (2021). Development of higher order thinking skill assessment instruments in learning Indonesian history. 10(2). https://doi.org/10.11591/ijere.v10i2.20796
Shanzey, P. (2025). The Effectiveness of Online Collaborative Learning through Digital Platforms in Enhancing Students ’ Communication Skills. 3(3), 110–119.
Siahaan, P., Dewi, E., & Suhendi, E. (2020). Introduction, connection, application, reflection, and extension (ICARE) learning model: The impact on students’ collaboration and communication skills. Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan Fisika Al-Biruni, 9(1), 109. https://doi.org/10.24042/jipfalbiruni.v9i1.5547
Sumilat, J. M. (2025). Differentiated Learning through ICARE Model to Improve Problem Solving Skills on the Material of Flat Shapes Area in Fifth Grade Elementary School (Issue Iceste). Atlantis Press SARL. https://doi.org/10.2991/978-2-38476-489-1
Suparni. (2016). Upaya meningkatkan kemampuan berpikir kritis mahasiswa menggunakan bahan ajar berbasis integrasi interkoneksi. 3(3), 40–58.
Suwarni, A., & Natsir, N. (2024). The Effectiveness of Project-Based Collaborative Learning in Improving English Speaking Skills of High School Students. December.
Usri, U., & Ikbal Salam, A. M. (2024). Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Collaborative Learning Design in Improving the Students’ Critical Thinking Ability in West Sulawesi Universities. International Journal of Economy, Education and Entrepreneurship (IJE3), 4(3), 668–680. https://doi.org/10.53067/ije3.v4i3.307
Wardani, I. S., & Fiorintina, E. (2023). Building Critical Thinking Skills of 21st Century Students through Problem Based Learning Model. 12(3), 461–470.
Zumrotus, D., Arnita, D., Mistika, H. P., & Sesba, H. K. (2025). Pentingnya Critical Thinking dalam Menghadapi Tantangan Dunia Kerja dan Kehidupan Sehari-Hari. November.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 International Journal of Emerging Research and Review
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
